• The Student Lawyer
  • Posts
  • The Trouble With Age Calls: Children's Rights, Short-Form Assessments And Local Authority Duties

The Trouble With Age Calls: Children's Rights, Short-Form Assessments And Local Authority Duties

Commercial awareness for regional and high street law, by the people doing it.

The Weekly Edge

Need to know

  • Under the Children’s Act 1989 s.17 obliges councils to safeguard children in need.

  • Sections 50 and 51 of the Nationality and Borders Act 2022 introduced a statutory framework for age assessments, including the National Age Assessment Board.

Table of Contents

Welcome to TSL’s Weekly Edge, whether you’re aiming for a regional or high-street practice, or just want to get a feel for how law works in the real world beyond textbooks, you’re in the right place. 

No corporate jargon, no massive deals, just real useful information designed to give you that extra edge in your legal journey.

🧠Wilson’s Weekly Wisdom

There is no substitute for seeing the law in action.

Recently, one of my colleagues who has worked in the litigation for a few years, told me they had never actually been to Court. A couple of weeks ago, they attended for the first time and came back saying just how much they had learnt from simply seeing it all happen in practice. It’s true, having that practical exposure is really valuable. 

You can read about Court procedure and understand how a hearing should work. But actually sitting in a Courtroom and watching the Judge, barristers and solicitors put it all into practice gives you a completely different understanding.

The same applies at university. Textbooks give you the foundations, but wherever you can, look for opportunities to see the law rather than just read about it. Attend a public hearing, undertake work experience or take part in a mooting competition.

📣 Your Turn: Ask Us Anything (Almost)

Got a question that’s been quietly bugging you about the legal world, commercial awareness, training contracts, or how regional firms actually work day to day? Good. We want it.

Each month, we’ll pick a question and do a an editorial response. No fluff. No corporate waffle. Just honest, practical answers you can actually use in applications, interviews, and real conversations in firms.

If you’re wondering it, chances are someone else is too. So be brave, be curious, and send it in.

👉 Submit your question here!

đź’ˇSpotlight Article

AI Image: Young girl holding her birth certificate

A child arrives in the UK alone. They say they’re 17, with little supporting documentation. Somehow, someone decides they’re an adult.

That means any support they’d otherwise get as a child, be it social care, safe accommodation or protection, is now up for fierce debate, leaving that child with another fight on their hands.

🔎What’s happening? 

If disputes sound like admin; dates, documents, tick‑boxes, it’s because they usually are.

But when the outcome decides whether someone gets the protection owed to a child, it stops being paperwork and becomes a much bigger deal. For an unaccompanied young person seeking asylum, being assessed as an adult can flip their entire support system upside down.

The even tougher bit?

Perhaps surprisingly, age isn’t always easy to pin down: documents go missing. Birth dates get disputed. Trauma can make accounts harder to assess. But councils can’t just eyeball someone and call it a day.

Under the Children Act 1989 (the Act), s.17 obliges councils to safeguard children in need, and s.20 addresses accommodation. If someone’s a child and meets the statutory conditions, these duties matter greatly.

But first, the council must determine whether the person’s under 18.

Let’s consider (B) v London Borough of Merton [2003], the case that gave us the rules for a Merton‑compliant age assessment.

In summary, the case made plain that councils should look beyond appearance and dig into backgrounds, family, education, experience, and credibility. They must run fair processes and not guess details.

What if the council decides a full assessment isn’t needed?

Then the short‑form version’s used instead. These shorter enquiries can be fine, if the circumstances justify it. The law doesn’t demand a marathon assessment every time. But even a short one must be fair and sufficient, which was the argument in R (HAM) v London Borough of Brent [2022].

The court pretty much said: forget rigid categories, as the level of investigation depends on the case. The Court of Appeal backed this up in R (SB) v Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea [2023]. Together, these cases make one thing clear: there’s no magic checklist.

What’s more important is whether the council made reasonable enquiries and followed a fair process, which raises questions: if the assessment was short, was it justified? Did they have enough info? Did they consider the right evidence? If they doubted credibility, did they give the young person a fair chance to respond? Or did they rely too much on appearance or behaviour?

Adding to the entanglement’s the accommodation problem.

If someone says they’re a child, gets assessed as an adult and ends up in unsuitable accommodation, waiting months for the dispute to finish isn’t realistic.

Section 20 of the Act may then become relevant if its conditions are met. Depending on the situation, a solicitor might need to pursue urgent judicial review and interim relief.

Granted, the section’s activation isn’t an automatic ticket to accommodation, as evidence and obligations count, but the assessment's ripple effects can’t be glossed over.

Immigration law adds another layer.

Ss. 50 and 51 of the Nationality and Borders Act 2022 introduced a statutory framework for age assessments, including the National Age Assessment Board. The Home Office also has safeguarding duties under s. 55 of the Borders, Citizenship and Immigration Act 2009.

The law doesn’t ask councils to be psychic. Instead, it asks they investigate properly, act fairly, and work within their existing responsibilities.

âť“ Why it matters to high street firms

If a solicitor’s advising a young person who’s been assessed as an adult, the first questions aren’t about whether anything feels wrong. They’re about what went wrong, what evidence supports a challenge, and what to do next.

In many cases, a procedural flaw can change everything.

That includes how the statutory framework operates, including provisions relating to the National Age Assessment Board. Maybe the council didn’t investigate properly. Maybe they ignored key evidence. Maybe they didn’t give the young person a decent chance to respond. Any of these can make the assessment vulnerable. Yet not every departure from guidance amounts to illegality. The decider’s whether the process was just and the enquiries sufficient.

Accommodation could also make things even more urgent.

Imagine a 17‑year‑old having to live among adults after a disputed assessment. They’re scared, unsupported and unsure what to do. A solicitor then has to look at both the age decision and the support question. If a legal basis exists, they may need urgent interim relief.

For high street firms, the job’s juggling public law, children’s social care and immigration, without losing sight of the young person in the middle.

Merton-compliant assessment

It’s a fair, lawful, and sufficiently thorough investigation into someone’s age, guided by Merton and the cases that followed.

It’s not, however, a universal checklist, as the depth of review depends on the circumstances. That said, the council still needs a justifiable basis for its conclusion.

🤔 So what?

🌟Interview gold:

It’s Free — Join Now to Keep Reading

Subscribe to The Student Lawyer (it’s free) to read the rest of this article.

I consent to receive newsletters via email. Sign up Terms of service.

Already a subscriber?Sign in.Not now